Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David C Hager, MD, MS's avatar

I see patients remotely now. Incredibly convenient for … me. But the problem I thought might happen has - a two dimensional emptiness that emphasizes my own evolutionary psychology patient education material.

We are one of countless social species because this basic instinct allowed us to survive through various versions over millions of years. A social instinct has allowed us to find food, protect ourselves and procreate more effectively. We are wired for this at the DNA level - to communicate through affective resonance and pheromones, and to be physically touched. Lives in misalignment with basic genetic wiring become ill … and in this case empty/depressed, like Harlow’s monkeys.

Expand full comment
Khải Đơn's avatar

As a poet and nonfiction writer, I can see how frustrated many writers feel. This debate over if we need writers anymore or if poetry is really useful for anyone if a prompt can give you a better poem than a human poet. This adds up to this anxiety of disconnection that Birgitte mentioned in the ssay. I also see some of my advertising clients use AI as an excuse to bargain with writers because "AI can do it faster and better".

However, I myself have been using AI in my work and see how they generate the content for work. They are at average quality, easy to copy and easy to find everywhere on the internet. There is lacking of unique point or strong human touch in it.

By that token, I struggle everyday to write a poem or an essay that helps me to grasp with the reality or to reflect my emotional state with the reality. Those valuable response of writing, just like physical exercise, can't be replaced to AI. Of course, I can ask AI to write me a poem to "show up", but I can't ask it to help me walk through the mental process that helps me expand my living experience. For that, as a selfish (and not so talented) writer, I still write for my own experience, I don't ask AI write me a poem. A tool can take over your daily life if you let it. But if you use it as a tool, it is a tool. I have been using AI for work in the last six months, I don't feel the loneliness of disconnected feeling between my work and myself.

I do feel at odd with some clients' conversations (as the essay said) but I guess that is part of the industry I work in.

Thank you so much for the thoughtful essay.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts